GUEST COMMENT
Keeping Up With Real-Time Risk:
New Solutions Needed
BY ALLAN D. GRODY
Now that regulators across the globe are both overseers and indirect owners of financial institutions, they will need risk management tools to better inform their new principal shareholder—the taxpayer. They will find that there is currently a lack of meaningful ways to do this, despite the fact that these institutions have long functioned as shareholder-owned, regulated and externally audited entities.
Financial institutions’ risk management approaches are constructed around business units organized within a hierarchy of accountability. Accountability is accomplished by managing the automated systems and human processes operating on supposedly trusted data that support the firms’ internal controls, transfer pricing schemes, unit costing models and performance attribution systems. When synchronized through management reporting systems they provide the prerequisites for a risk culture that can be monitored and managed, rewarding employees for meeting profitability targets within the parameters of the firm’s appetite for risk.
However, such a firm-wide risk appetite—prescribed by regulation, defined by the board and supervised by management—
has failed us. In recent testimony before Congress, Alan Greenspan acknowledged that he incorrectly assumed managers of financial firms were aligning their risk appetite to their shareholders’ interests. What he did not say was that executives had aligned their appetite for risk to their own individual interests and that risk and accountability controls failed regulators.
The typical controls—retrospectively auditing firms once per year, or reviewing their internal controls at a point in time—were never up to the task of monitoring risk expo-
Allan Grody
sure in real time. Nor, more importantly, were they capable of doing so when executive compensation is tied to annual profitability performance without adjusting for long-term risk. The problem—the inability to measure and control risk exposures—is caused by the lack of transparency within these businesses due to their siloed organizational structures, the pervasiveness of faulty data, and the misaligned incentives for individual reward that fail to balance risk and return with short-term self-interest and long-term stakeholder goals.
ket prices, and other reference information.
When included in a transaction, non-standardized data elements that are incorrectly sourced or identified have the potential to cause losses due to processing exceptions or trade failures. Improperly retrieving a description for a security in order to access its internal code causes transactions to be misidentified. Huge additional costs are incurred by firms in employing a vast array of people, processes and systems for reconciliation and work-around activities. And a vast infrastructure of payment and settlement facilities are needed to match separately sourced transactional data to control the errors that occur from mismatched identity and attribute elements.
U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson, in the department’s March proposal for a regulatory overhaul, identified payment and settlement systems as among the more important systemic risks that lack coordinated regulation. Relying on such automated systems without a common data language means that transaction details cannot be aggregated in a meaningful or timely way, settled seamlessly, or monitored effectively by regulators and company management for real-time risk exposure.
VOLUME XX, NUMBER 42 EDITORIAL
MANAGING EDITOR
MICHAEL EGGEBRECHT..................(212) 803-8470
michael.eggebrecht@sourcemedia.com
ART DIRECTOR
FRITZ LAURORE .............................(212) 803-8259
SENIOR INTERNATIONAL EDITOR
CHRIS KENTOURIS .........................(212) 803-8412
chressa.kentouris@sourcemedia.com
SPECIAL REPORTS EDITOR
CAROL E. CURTIS ..........................(203) 359-2803
carol.curtis@sourcemedia.com
STANDARDS EDITOR
JOHN SANDMAN .............................(212) 803-8422
john.sandman@sourcemedia.com
SENIOR EDITOR
ALEXA JAWORSKI ............................(212) 803-8407
alexa.jaworski@sourcemedia.com
MARKETS REPORTER
DAWN KISSI ...................................(212) 803-6087
dawn.kissi@sourcemedia.com
CORRESPONDENTS
JANICE FIORAVANTE (TECHNOLOGY)
jfioravante@yahoo.com
KATHERINE HEIRES (TECHNOLOGY)
mediakat@earthlink.net
JOHN HINTZE (SELL-SIDE)
johnhintze@yahoo.com
SHANE KITE (FIXED INCOME/BUY-SIDE)
skribe88@nyc.rr.com
MICHAEL SISK (FRONT END)
michaelasisk@yahoo.com
MARIA TROMBLY (ASIA/TECHNOLOGY)
maria@tromblyltd.com
MELANIE WOLD (MARKET DATA)
mwold@localnet.com
BUSINESS
VP & GROUP PUBLISHER
DAN RUBINETTI.............................(212) 803-6062
daniel.rubinetti@sourcemedia.com
NATIONAL ADVERTISING DIRECTOR
MICHAEL SIMONE ..........................(212) 803-8289
michael.simone@sourcemedia.com
NATIONAL ADVERTISING DIRECTOR
ERIC KELLIHER..............................(212) 803-6052
eric.kelliher@sourcemedia.com
VP BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT ADAM REINEBACH ..........................(212) 803-6555 adam.reinbach@sourcemedia.com MARKETING KATHERINE ISACSSON ....................(212) 803-8173 katherine.isacsson@sourcemedia.com DIRECTOR, AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT MICHAEL O’CONNOR.....................(212) 803-8324 michaeloconnor@sourcemedia.com CUSTOMER SERVICE (800) 221-1809 OR (212) 803-8333 custserv@sourcemedia.com REPRINTS/WEB RIGHTS/PERMISSIONS GODFREY R. LIVERMORE................(888) 909-6366 godfrey.livermore@sourcemedia.com
The complexity and level of automation in today’s financial services industry has leapfrogged the once cherished risk management techniques practiced by partnerships—the dominant governance model only three decades ago. At the time, a Monday morning meeting at which the partners decided how to allocate the company’s capital for the week was all the risk management that was needed. Big rewards were bestowed only on those whose personal capital was on the line.
Today, these investment and capital market partnerships are global in scope—many are now embedded in multinational banking institutions, largely owned by public shareholders. Partners have been replaced by staff whose pay schemes give them big rewards at bonus time for taking big risks with shareholders’ capital. In good times the executives take the money off the table, with upward of 50 percent of revenues falling into their collective pockets. In bad times shareholders foot the bill and no one asks for the money back.
MANUFACTURING
ELINA SHNAYDER...........................(212) 803-8210
PRODUCTION COORDINATOR ROD HARROP.................................(212) 803-8520 DISTRIBUTION MARK FERRARA..............................(212) 803-8302 EVP & MANAGING DIRECTOR, BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY & SECURITIES DIVISION ROBERT WHITAKER........................(212) 803-8844 robert.whitaker@sourcemedia.com
The failure to aggregate basic data across vast enterprises is at the root of the failure to monitor risk at the same time that risks are being taken. If there is to be a solution, financial systems’ data identity elements—the building blocks of all financial products—must be standardized and categorized. These components represent 70 percent of the data elements that define financial instruments, counterparties, valuation and mar-
SOURCEMEDIA, INC.
JAMES M. MALKIN................................CHAIRMAN & CEO WILLIAM H. JOHNSTON.............................................CFO STEVE ANDREAZZA.........VP, SALES & CUSTOMER SERVICE RICHARD ANTONECK.........SVP, FINANCE & ACCOUNTING JEFF SCOTT..........................PRESIDENT, BANKING GROUP HUGH JONES ....................................PRESIDENT, ACCUI TY CELIE BAUSSAN......................................SVP, OPERATIONS DAVID LONGOBARDI ......EVP & CHIEF CONTENT OFFICER ANNE O’BRIEN .......................................EVP, MARKETING
& S TRATEGIC PLANNING
HOLLY SRAEEL........................SVP, BRAND MANAGEMENT YING WONG........SENIOR DIRECTOR, HUMAN RESOURCES
Allan D. Grody is president of Financial InterGroup and a former professor of risk management at New York University’s Stern School of Business.
Risk managers have been focused for too long on models of past losses as a means of calculating risk capital. They have forgone the challenge of adapting operating metrics to risk exposure
Continued on page 8
SUBSCRIP TIONS (888) 807-8667 SECURI TIES INDUSTRY NEWS ISSN: 1089-6333 IS PUBLISHED WEEKLY EXCEPT FOR 1/1, 7/2, 7/16, 7/30, 8/13, 8/27, 10/13, 11/26, 12/3, 12/24 AND 12/31 BY SOURCEMEDIA, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. ONE STATE S TREET PLAZA, 27 TH FLOOR, NE W YORK, NY 10004. (POSTMASTER: SEND ADDRESS CHANGES TO: SECURITIES INDUSTRY NEWS/SOURCEMEDIA, P.O. BOX 530, CONGERS, N Y 10920) PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID AT NEW YORK, NY AND ADDITIONAL MAILING OFFICES STANDARD (A) MAIL. ( SUBSCRIPTION RATES: IN U.S., $575 FOR ONE YEAR; INTERNATIONAL, $699 FOR ONE YEAR). BULK SUBSCRIP TIONS AVAILABLE. THOSE REGIS TERED WI TH THE COP YRIGHT CLEARANCE CENTER HAVE PERMISSION TO PHOTOCOPY ARTICLES OWNED BY SECURITIES INDUS TRY NE WS FOR A FLAT FEE OF $10 PER COP Y OF EACH ARTICLE. SEND PAYMENT TO COP YRIGHT CLEARANCE CENTER, 222 ROSEWOOD DRIVE, DANVERS, MA 01923. COPYRIGHT 2008, SECURITIES INDUS TRY NEWS AND SOURCEMEDIA, INC.
References:
Archives